Wednesday, December 2, 2015

ACC/BIG 10 CHALLENGE PLAYER RATINGS: NORTH CAROLINA v MARYLAND & VIRGINIA vs OHIO STATE

Last night was an excellent night of basketball, as the ACC/Big 10 challenge got into full swing. Here is my first post recapping last night's games. This post will cover VIRGINIA @ OHIO STATE, and MARYLAND @ NORTH CAROLINA. It will include player ratings for all teams.

I am still working on another post covering last night's games, which I plan on releasing later this afternoon before tonight's slate of games begin. Tomorrow I will have  a player ratings post covering tonight's games, and Friday I will release a post covering any games I did not get to today or tomorrow. So, stay tuned because there is more excitement to come. Let me know what your take on last night's big matchups was.

10 VIRGINIA 64 @ OHIO STATE 58
Virginia Cavaliers
C Jack Salt: 4
Well, last time I saw Virginia play (which was back at the beginning of the season), I started the #FreeSalt campaign. He is starting now at center for the Cavaliers, but he only played nine minutes against. Salt and fellow center, Mike Tobey combined for only 27 minutes. So, Virginia chose to play smaller with Wilkins and Gill down low this game. Salt did not get a chance to do much this game. He was just 1-3 shooting, and is not a skilled scorer in the post. He also only had one rebound. Ohio State found some success attacking the basket when Salt came out of the game early in the second half.
F Anthony Gill: 6
Anthony Gill is a consistent frontcourt player for the Cavaliers. He is capable of making mid range jumpers, but most of Gill's points come from close to the basket. He is especially good at scoring off of offensive rebounds. These factors make Gill a usually high percentage scorer, although not a dynamic one. He was just 3-8 against OSU, scoring ten points. Gill is a good rebounder, and had eight this game, three of which came off the offensive glass. Gill struggled defensively against Jae'Sean Tate. I personally found some of Virginia's defensive alignments strange, and this was one of the matchups I questioned. Tate is much smaller than Gill; he's 6'4, but is a terrific athlete, and consistently beat Gill off the dribble, and when moving without the ball.
G Marial Shayok: 3
Shayok is an inconsistent shooter. The stats would have you believe he is a 62% shooter who has made 60% of his 3pt attempts. However, through six games Shayok has scored in double figures three times, while he has scored four points or less in the other three games. Shayok was only 1-5 this game, scoring two points. He does not contribute much apart from his shooting. He is not a rebounder, and not a great individual defender, though he had a steal in this game.
G Malcolm Brogdon: 9
Malcolm Brogdon shot just 3-10 in the first half, but he stepped up his game in the second, shooting 4-6, and leading Virginia down the stretch. He scored 22 points total, and shot 6-10 from 3pt range. Brogdon also had six rebounds (all on the defensive end), and two assists. Brogdon did struggle at times against Marc Loving defensively, especially when Loving decided to take the ball to the basket. Brogdon picked up three fouls in the second half when Loving drove to the basket. This was another defensive mismatch in my opinion. I would have had Brogdon on Tate, and Gill on Loving—but what do I know. Perhaps Tony Bennett figured Loving would force Gill too far away from the basket defensively.
G Darius Thompson: 8.5
Thompson received the start at the point guard positon in London Perrantes' absence. He did a good job stepping up, and shared ball handling responsibilities with Malcolm Brogdon. Thompson showed off some good offensive ability. He shot 5-8 from the field, and made two of his three 3pt attempts, for a total of 12 points, which ties a season high for him. He also dished out six assists this game, and only turned the ball over twice. Thompson's shooting potency this game, helped to free up Brogdon, and the two worked really well together. Thompson did a nice job containing JaQuan Lyle on defense as well, especially down the stretch as he prevented Lyle from getting a good shot off late in the game.
F Isaiah Wilkins: 6
Wilkins was once again the first player off of Virginia's bench. He scored two of three shot attempts, scoring a total of six points. He finished the game with five rebounds, two on the offensive end. He also played solid defense inside, and delivered Virginia's lone block of the game. Wilkins is a solid defender. He has a similar skill set to Anthony Gill, and I consider him Gill Lite. Although, Wilkins is not capable of making a jump shot. He was the better defender this game though, as he was not tasked with Tate.
G Devon Hall: 3.5
With London Perrantes out this game, Devon Hall received an increase in minutes. He played 24, or more than half the game. Despite this, he scored only four points, which is below his season average, on two for five shooting, and missed his only 3pt attempt. Hall grabbed three rebounds though. Hall played defensively against the bigger Keita Bates-Diop in the second half, but OSU did not attack this matchup like I thought they would.
C Mike Tobey: 4.5
Mike Tobey has been benched for the more defensive Jack Salt since I've last seen the Cavaliers play. In my first review of the team at the beginning of the season I criticized Tobey for being defensively deficient, despite his 7'0 size, saying “he provided no bite under the basket.” By saying that though, I DID NOT MEAN TO BENCH HIM, AND PLAY HIM ONLY 18 MINUTES A GAME! Tobey is a terrific scorer, and can score in a variety of ways both in the post, and shooting jumpers away from the basket. Virginia's biggest problem is the lack of a go-to scorer outside of Brogdon. It confounds me why Virginia would have Tobey sit on the bench for a majority of the game, when he shoots nearly 60% from the field, and is far-and-away their best low post scorer. Despite playing only 18 minutes per game, Tobey is still scoring nearly 10 points on average, while grabbing 5.5 rebounds per game. No, as I have suggested before, Tobey is not going to be a great interior defender, but I don't think replacing him is a worthwhile tradeoff. So, I am starting a new movement for the sake of Virginia fans. #FreeTobey.
Now...back to the game against Ohio State. Tobey came off the bench, and shot two of three from the field, scoring six points total. Virginia really did not try to get him involved in the offense. He also only grabbed one rebound. Tobey was little help preventing OSU's forwards from attacking the basket in the second half, but neither was anyone else for UVA.
F Evan Nolte: N/A
Did not play enough to qualify.
Team Rating: 6.30
Virginia could not break away from the Buckeyes, and this game was closely contested until the final 30 seconds. The Cavaliers had to overcome adversity with their starting point guard, London Perrantes, out following an appendectomy. Darius Thompson filled in exceedingly well, though. Malcolm Brogdon was his usual stellar self, and led the team to victory in the second half. To be completely honest, I'm still left with the same concerns about this Virginia team I was a month ago. They are going to struggle against teams that can score inside due to their lack of strong interior defenders, and they lack a go-to offensively player next to Brogdon. Gill is a nice consistent starter, but he isn't a dynamic offensive player. Maybe, if Tobey goes back to being the offensive player I saw at the beginning of the year, and Thompson proves to be the scorer I saw against Ohio State, there is enough offense to finish in the top-four in the ACC. But, I still do not think this is a team that can compete for another conference title.
Ohio State Buckeyes
C Daniel Giddens: 6
Giddens is the first of four four-star freshman who played in this game for OSU. Giddens proved to be a great interior defender, making the Cavaliers very jealous. Giddens blocked four shots, and did so while only fouling twice in 25 minutes. Giddens looked pretty nonexistent on the offensive end though. He took only two shots, making one, for a total of two points. He also turned the ball over twice. Giddens did have an assist. He received the ball against the baseline, was double teamed, and passed the ball across court to Lyle who was open for a three pointer. Disappointingly, Giddens also only had one rebound this game. Giddens is a terrific interior defender, and will receive a lot of minutes as a result, but he still needs to develop his offensive game. He could become a dominate big man though.
F Keita Bates-Diop: 6.5
Bates-Diop is one of three perimeter based forwards who start for the Buckeyes. He was a five-star recruit just last year, and is one of many high upside players on this team. Bates-Dip took six of his eight field goal attempts from beyond the arc this game, making three of them. He shot 50% (4-8) overall, and scored 15 points. Bates-Diop was a passive part of the offense, as it seemed to flow through Loving, Tate, and Lyle. I got frustrated by Bates-Diop in the second half, especially down the stretch, because he kept taking 3pt shots whenever he touched the ball. He was being guarded by the smaller Devon Hall, and I would have liked to have seen him drive more against Virginia. Bates-Diop has not shot well from 3pt range this season, under 30%, so I guess he was feeling hot tonight, and tried to make the most of it. Oh well. Don't get me wrong, he still had a really good game offensively. However, I think Ohio State could have won this game, and this was a mismatch they failed to exploit. Bates-Diop did not rebound well this game, only grabbing two boards. This may be because he played on the perimeter so much this game.
F Jae'Sean Tate: 8
Jae'Sean Tate is an interesting player. He is a thick 6'4, and built like a linebacker. He proved to be extremely versatile on the offensive end against Virginia. He shot 5-9 for 12 points, moving well with and without the ball. Anthony Gill had trouble staying with him, and Tate punished him a couple of times when Gill strayed off of him to help on a double team. Tate is a surprisingly good ball handler, and often drove to the basket, where he was able to score at the rim, and also pass out to open shooters. He turned the ball over only once. One of the most improved areas of Tate's game this year is his jump shooting. He shot just 15.8% from three last season, but is shooting 33.3% this year, and was one of two this game (not that he will ever be Malcolm Brogdon or anything). Tate is good rebounder, and led his team in that area with eight boards. Tate guarded Anthony Gill often defensively, and struggled against him in the post, as Gill could easily shoot right over him. I don't like him defending power forwards; they are just too tall for him.
F Marc Loving: 8
Loving led OSU in points this game, like he has all year. He shot an impressive 7-11 from the field, and three of six from beyond the arc, for a total of 19 points. Loving found as much success driving on the smaller Malcolm Brogdon as he did shooting from outside. It was nice to see OSU's lone upperclassman acknowledge that mismatch, and take advantage. Despite shooting well most of the game, Loving helped OSU make some critical mistakes down the stretch. Virginia got the lead back to six points following a Brogdon three with about six minutes to go. Loving and Lyle then each missed 3pt attempts early in the shot clock on back-to-back possessions. Loving then turned the ball over twice in the following minutes while driving to the basket. Then Ohio State lost. So, Loving played really well most of the game, and helped Ohio State stay in the game. However, he did not play like a veteran during the game's final six minutes, and that led to the team's loss.
G JaQuan Lyle: 2
Lyle was the weak link for Ohio State against UVA. The four-star freshman has a heavy burden on him, taking the place of DeAngelo Russell. He shot poorly this game, making only one of his seven attempts from the field; six of his shots came from beyond the arc, including his lone made field goal. He ended the game with just three points. Lyle's three point attempts often came either very early in the possession, when better shots could have been had, or with the shot clock expiring. Lyle often found the ball in his hands with time expiring, which credit Virginia's defense for. Lyle's only made shot came after Tate dribbled into the middle, drawing a second defender, and leaving Lyle open. Lyle did have four assists, and had some mild success penetrating, and looking for open teammates. However, he also lost the ball while driving, and never looked to score inside. The development of Lyle as a point guard is the biggest factor for OSU moving forward.
C Trevor Thompson: 6
Trevor Thompson played some really good minutes off the bench, proving to be an effective replacement for Giddens. He scored five points on 2-3 shooting. He also grabbed five rebounds. Despite not recording a blocked shot, Thompson played good post defense.
G Austin Grandstaff: 2
Grandstaff is yet another four-star freshman. He played quite a bit down the stretch, but was incredibly unimpressive. He missed his only three points attempt (he's a 3pt specialist who is shooting 42.1% from beyond the arc this year), and played some really poor defense. Even though he was matched up against Virginia's least effective backcourt scorer, Hall.
G Kam Williams: N/A
Did not play enough to qualify.
G AJ Harris: N/A
Did not play enough to qualify.
Team Rating: 5.85
Considering they were playing the tenth ranked team in the nation, I suppose this is a positive performance for Ohio State. However, he must be frustrating for the team, because they could have (should have) beaten Virginia. Unfortunately, they panicked with about six minutes left in the game, and completely fell apart offensively. I think you can confidently say this is the best two win team in the country. Ohio State is overflowing with potential, and it will be interesting to see how much they are able to improve the remainder of the season. Loving, Bates-Diop, and Tate give the Buckeyes three versatile forwards offensively, while Giddens provides them with a great interior defender. However, they need a low post presence offensively, and Lyle needs to mature quickly, and become a better game manager.

2 MARYLAND 81 @ 9 NORTH CAROLINA 89
Maryland Terrapins
C Diamond Stone: 6
Diamond Stone had a quiet game against North Carolina. He shot four of seven, scoring nine points, which falls in line with his season average. Stone struggled with Kennedy Meeks guarding him. Meeks did a good job of denying him the ball, and standing strong in the post when Stone did get the ball. It's just disappointing to see the top-ten recruit settling for mediocrity on the offensive end. I would liked to see him get the ball in the post seeing as he is bigger than any of North Carolina's players. He could have at least tried to draw fouls on UNC's Meeks and Brice Johnson, instead the duo only had two and one foul respectively. Stone hit a a turnaround jumper from the baseline from about 15 feet out, that one play really impressed me, and showed a glimpse of his potential. Stone's nine point scoring average isn't actually bad considering he only plays 16.7 minutes a game. I don't know why he is playing so little. Maybe it's conditioning, or maybe Maryland just hasn't needed him as of yet, and are still trying to ease him into the college game. Whatever the reason. He will need to be a more dominate player on both ends of the court, and for longer stretches if Maryland is to challenge for a Final Four bid this season. Stone also had five rebounds, three of which were off the offensive glass.
F Robert Carter: 7.5
Robert Carter looked good against North Carolina. He is a versatile forward, who has big size, he's 6'9, is athletic, and can shoot. He shot 5-8 from the field, and 1-3 from 3pt range, scoring a total of 11 points. The transfer from Georgetown is shooting over 60% from the field thus far this season. I think Maryland needs to make a more conscious effort to make him (and Stone) a bigger part of the offense. Carter also looked good on the defensive end blocking four shots (Maryland only had six as a team); he also had two steals. Although, he only grabbed five rebounds, and turned the ball over three times. Carter finished the game with four fouls, but he was never in foul trouble. He picked up two fouls in the final minute of the game.
F Jake Layman: 4.5
This was a high scoring game, but Jake Layman was one of the few players who struggled offensively. He could not get himself going on offense. Layman shot 1-5 from the field, and missed all three of his 3pt attempts. Layman has been shooting poorly from beyond the arc all season. He's made less than 29% of his attempts, compared to 38% last season. During the broadcast, Jay Bilas suggested his struggles may be due to playing the three more often this season, rather than being employed as a stretch-four. So, he is facing quicker, more athletic wings. Layman was another player responsible for three turnovers. He did grab eight rebounds though.
G Rasheed Sulaimon: 7.5
Rasheed Sulaimon is experiencing a career rejuvenation in his final year of eligibility. He shot 6-12 from the field, and 5-9 from beyond the arc, scoring 18 points. He is shooting over 50% from both the field, and from three thus far this season, which is pretty incredible. He is also proving to be a good passer and creator. He is averaging 3.4 assists per game, and had three against UNC. Sulaimon's struggles came on the defensive end this game though. He struggled against the returning Marcus Paige, and looked to be growing frustrated as the game wore on, especially after slamming into a couple of Tar Heel screens, which dropped him. He also had three turnovers.
G Melo Trimble: 8.5
Trimble shows flashes of brilliance when he looks like the best point guard in the country. He took charge for the first thirteen minutes of the second half, and led Maryland back to take the lead, before UNC pulled away in the closing minutes. He looked tremendous off the dribble, and made Nate Britt look completely silly on a crossover. Trimble is capable of making every shot offensively. He ended the game 8-14, making four of his five attempts from 3pt range. He scored a game high 23 points. Trimble is an excellent passer, and had several highlight reel dishes this game. He finished with a career high 12 assists, giving Trimble his first double-double of the season. On the other side though, Trimble turned the ball over an outrageous EIGHT times. That's inexcusable. Trimble has only turned the ball over more than twice in a game on one other occasion this year (four against Illinois State), which leads me to believe that North Carolina did an excellent job of forcing Trimble to make mistakes. Trimble's performance was nearly perfect, but unfortunately too many turnovers (the team had 22) caused the team to lose.
F Damonte Dodd: 5
Damonte Dodd matches Diamond Stone in size. He's listed at 6'11 250 lbs. He usually comes in in place of Stone. However, the two do play together at times, giving Maryland a big lineup. Dodd is not a dynamic scorer, but he gets some high percentage looks close to the basket. He made three of his five attempts, and scored six points agains the Tar Heels. He is shooting 70% from the field on the season. He also added two rebounds, and did a decentjob of preventing UNC from scoring inside
G Jared Nickens: 4
Nickens is a 3pt specialist. More than 80% of his shot attempts this season, and all of his against UNC, are from 3pt range. Nickens made two of his six three point shots, scoring six points. However, he missed a couple of wide open looks down the stretch, when Maryland was still in contention. Nickens provides little value outside of his shooting ability, and his favored defensive technique is fouling when he gets beat. He picked up four fouls, while playing twenty minutes this game.
C Michal Cekovsky: 5
Cekovsky gives Maryland some additional size at 7'1. He scored four point, and had three rebounds. He is an adequate back up center, but I would rather see Stone play more minutes.
Team Rating: 6.40
Maryland shot the ball really well: 50.8% form the field, and 46.2% from three. Melo Trimble, Rasheed Sulaimon, and Robert Carter all looked very good on the offensive end. Trimble especially looked like one of the nation's premier players. However, the team turned the ball over way too many times. They cannot possibly expect to win games if they turn the ball over 20 times in a game. Perhaps, the problem was Maryland played too fast, and got suckered into an uptempo game by UNC. The Terrapins had no answer for North Carolina's offense, exemplified by Rasheed Sulaimon's face when he went crashing into Joel James' screen, while desperately trying to stop Marcus Paige. Maryland still looks like a top-five team to me. Trimble is a star, and he has great complements around him in Sulaimon and Carter. They will be even more dangerous if Diamond Stone can start living up to his potential.
North Carolina Tar Heels
F Kennedy Meeks: 8
Kennedy Meeks was his usual solid self on offense against Maryland. He shot 6 of 11 from the field, scoring 12 points. Meeks even made a long jump shot from just inside the arc. He also had six rebounds, three of which came on the offensive end. However, it was on the defensive end that he really shined. Meeks did a great job of jumping in front of passes destined for the post, and had three steals this game. He also blocked a pair of shots, and overall did a nice job preventing clean looks in front of the basket. Meeks also did a nice job staying out of foul trouble; he finished the game with only two.
F Brice Johnson: 7
Brice Johnson continues to prove he is a supremely talented scorer anywhere in the post. He a multitude of moves with which he can score. Johnson shot 7-12 from the field, scoring 16 points. Johnson was held to only six rebounds this game, and did not get any off the offensive glass. This partly could be because North Carolina shot over 50% from the field though.
F Justin Jackson: 7
Previous to this game, Jackson had scored more than 20 points in three straight games. However, he failed to reach even ten against Maryland. Jackson shot 3-7, making one of his two 3pt attempts. He also turned the ball over three times. Like Meeks though, Jackson's greatest contribution this game was on the defensive end. Jackson was a menace disrupting passing lanes. He finished the game with five steals, and created even more turnovers often leading to easy points for North Carolina.
G Marcus Paige: 10
What a difference Marcus Paige makes on this team. He made his season debut against Maryland, and energized his team. Paige began the game with an assist to Meeks. He then hit a 3pt shot on the following possession. In the second half he scored eight points in a two minute span to keep his team ahead. In all, Paige shot 7-12, and 4-5 from beyond the arc. He scored a team high 20 points. Paige's presence also opened up teammates; he recorded five assists. In a game where the two teams combined to turn the ball over 37 times, Paige was only responsible for one of the turnovers. He also played good defense, disrupting passing lanes, and coming away with two steals.
G Joel Berry: 7
Despite Paige's return, Berry still played 32 minutes against Maryland. He shot really well form beyond the arc this game, 3-5, and scored 14 points total. Berry also finished the game with five assists, and two steals, while turning the ball over twice. Berry missed some free throws in the final minutes when the outcome of the game was still in contention, and only made 3 of his 7 attempts from the line. I personally, prefer Nate Britt to Berry. He's a better shooter. He plays better defense, and he turns the ball over less. However, it is clear UNC is going to go with Berry, and he did not discourage them with his performance against Maryland.
F Isaiah Hicks: 6
Isaiah Hicks is one of my favorite frontcourt reserves in the ACC (although he certainly is not ahead of Syracuse's Tyler Lydon). He has good size, and is athletic. He can be an asset on offense, defense, and rebounding. He can make a jumper as well. That said, Hicks did not have the most memorable game against Maryland, playing only fifteen minutes. He shot 2-3 for four points, and added six rebounds.
F Theo Pinson: 5.5
Theo Pinson lost his starting spot to Marcus Paige. He and Nate Britt will have their minutes reduced the most due to Paige's return. Pinson played just 18 minutes this game, despite averaging 27 minutes on the season. Pinson is not a great scorer. He had only six points, on 1-3 shooting this game. However, he is a terrific passer especially for his size, and he dished out a pair of assists. He is averaging just under five assists per game. Pinson also grabbed four rebounds.
G Nate Britt: 8
Britt was one of the minutes casualties with Marcus Paige returning. He played only ten minutes. Britt shot 2-5, making his only 3pt attempt, and scoring 5 points. He also dished out three assists during his short time on the court. Unfortunately for Britt, his most memorable moment on the court was when he fell down, fooled by a Melo Trimble crossover.
F Joel James: 3.5
James is UNC's designated get dirty player. He comes out, and just plays physical. He grabbed just one rebound this game. Turned the ball over twice, and picked up three fouls. On the bright side though, he made a nice turnaround jumper, causing me to confuse him for Brice Johnson for just a moment.
Team Rating: 7.45

Marcus Paige immediately makes North Carolina look like a title contender again. The two best performances I have seen this season are Kentucky's win over Duke, and now North Carolina's win over Maryland. Those two teams are one and two for me, and no one else is close—of the team's I have seen—and that includes Michigan State. Marcus Paige gave UNC an edge offensively that they had lacked prior to this game. He also plays with such confidence that the entire team is elevated on both sides of the ball. He is a really fun player to watch. The frontcourt players, Brice Johnson and Kennedy Meeks, have had better games offensively, but they deferred to the shooters this game. North Carolina made an incredible 69% of their 3pt attempts (9-13). No, they won't always shoot that well. However, I trust that when they don't the post players will step their game up. The balance and explosiveness on offense is unmatched in college basketball. Kentucky is just as explosive, maybe more so, but they aren't as balanced. North Carolina also showed some good defense despite Maryland scoring 81 points, and shooting over 50%. This is because the Tar Heels grabbed 13 steals, and forced Maryland to commit 22 turnovers. Kennedy Meeks, Justin Jackson, and Marcus Paige were especially impressive on defense. This game just started a whole new season for North Carolina.

No comments:

Post a Comment